Results Based HR Strategy

Stalked By Supervisor on Facebook and Then Fired

Q. I didn’t realize my supervisor had linked to my Facebook profile. She made up an assumed name and profile and friended me and two stalkedcomputer 300x198 Stalked By Supervisor on Facebook and Then Firedother employees who she perceived as troublemakers but who both left the company months ago.

This came to light last Friday when I got fired.

During the meeting I said how I’d always loyally supported her and she said, “What about when you said …?”

I said I never said that. She quoted from my personal Facebook page where I’d said she was a world class witch. Isn’t that illegal stalking?

What happened to free speech? And to what you do on your own time is none of your employer’s business?

Can you recommend a good attorney?

A. Good attorneys don’t like bad cases.

Instead of focusing on suing, learn so you don’t wind up in this fix again. When you publicly gripe and your employer sees it, free speech costs.

When Amy McCleanathan wrote, “I’d like to get fired, pretty please …” on her Facebook account, Amy’s employer canned her — legally.

What? Wasn’t she writing on her own time, own equipment and didn’t she have the right to free speech?

No. Employees who complain on the public forum Facebook don’t have protected speech. Employers have the right to say, “We don’t like what you’ve said and don’t want to keep paying someone who acts out like this.”

Further, the National Labor Relations Act, which protects both unionized and nonunionized employees who band together to protest poor working conditions, only extends to employees talking with other employees in “protected concerted activity” and not to employees venting.

To qualify for NLRA protection, your comments would need to focus on wages, working conditions or job performance and be directed to or on behalf of fellow employees who respond to you, rather than your own individual complaint.

Also, although the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) challenged many Facebook and social media terminations in 2012, the federal Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit recently invalidated President Obama’s 2012 appointments to the NLRB because he made them when the Senate was in recess. As a result, prior NLRB decisions on behalf of employees protesting terminations may not hold.

Further, states attorney Eric Meyer, Partner in the Labor & Employment Group at Dilworth Paxson LLP, “while the NLRB has announced its intention to conduct business as usual pending a definitive ruling on the constitutionality of President Obama’s recess appointments, don’t count on the NLRB watering down ‘protected concerted activity’ to afford protection to an individual griper.”

Next, a loophole in Facebook’s privacy settings makes Facebook stalking hard to track or stop. Although Facebook tries to crack down on pseudonyms, its organizers admit that more than 83 million fake accounts exist.

Given what you’ve discovered, you have recourse. Report your former supervisor to Facebook and they’ll pull down your supervisor’s profile. Speak to the manager above your supervisor and document this creepy behavior. When you do, your supervisor may join you in the unemployment line or the manager may rescind your firing. If your supervisor accompanied this cyber-spying with other actions and truly stalked you, call the police.

Meanwhile, reflect on your role in this. You vented publicly. You can never shovel back into your mouth words voiced to another or on social media. You also did what many do and too loosely accepted friend requests.

Finally, do you want to work for a supervisor who spies on you? Occasionally, being fired can be a blessing.

 

 

 Stalked By Supervisor on Facebook and Then Fired

About Lynne Curry, Ph.d., SPHR

Lynne Curry, Ph.D., SPHR and owner of the Alaska-based management consulting firm, The Growth Company Inc. consults with companies and individuals to create real solutions to real workplace challenges. Their services include HR On-call (a-la-carte HR), investigations, mediation, management/employee training, executive coaching, 360/employee reviews and organizational strategy services. You can reach Lynne @ www.thegrowthcompany.com, via her workplace 911/411 blog, www.workplacecoachblog.com or @lynnecurry10 on twitter.

2 comments

  1. Michael Janas /

    I agree with you Lynne. I would also say that dependent on what State the complainant resides in, they may also have legal recourse based on any labor and/or communications laws that may be on the books. A good labor attorney could help, at minimal cost.

    Secondly, if the company has an Employee Handbook, does it contain a “Business Conduct” or “Ethics” section. Could the supervisor’s behavior be considered a breach of that section? If so, report it to the HR dept or entity that processes such complaints. Maybe the former supervisor will be in the unemployment line with the complainant; at the very least, they will be on disciplinary notice by the employer. I would also suggest you go up your ex-supervisor’s chain of command to the more senior level (Dir, VP)where the situation won’t get lost in the day-to-day shop floor chaos.

    In addition, if all the ex-employees impacted by that supervisor’s Internet stalking behavior were to come together, there could be a potential class action lawsuit as an available recourse.

    Also, and most importantly, as you stated Lynne ‘do you really want to work where this type of behavior (Internet stalking) takes place?’ My 30 yrs in HR says “no”.

    I agree with Lynne: your termination was a blessing.

  2. Beth Agen /

    Hi Lynne. I think much of the regulations surrounding “Facebook firings” will vary state-by-state for the time being. Interestingly it’s not the free speech argument that it going to win, it is the “protected concerted activity”. Connecticut, where I live, had a very interesting case a few years ago. I remember it well while it was happening.
    http://www.ctemploymentlawblog.com/2011/09/articles/nlrb-administrative-law-judge-facebook-firings-illegal/

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Could Two Employees Take Down Your Business? | HR C-Suite - [...] Tom Daniel and Danielle Ryman, employers need to get a handle on their employees’ use of social media including …
  2. You Owe it to Yourself to Blow the Whistle: Washington | HR C-Suite - [...] consider going to the General Manager but hesitate. He and your supervisor are fishing buddies. You confide in a …
  3. Non-Essential and Public Hot Flashes | HR C-Suite - […] this way. Being sent home as “not necessary” is one heck of a slap in the face. My supervisor …
  4. Blameless | HR C-Suite - […] of handling the situation or apologizing to you for what you’ve had to put up with, your supervisor slams …
  5. The Tried-And-True Model for Building Employee Engagement | HR C-Suite - […] 2:  Managers and supervisors focus on meeting specific needs of their individual employees. Here, managers can, systematically, […]
  6. Manager HR Skills: Hiding the Problem | HR C-Suite - […] Because this problem blew up, I became the scapegoat. Was this or was this not an unfair firing? […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This blog is monetized using Are-PayPal WP Plugin